Virtual reality at your fingertips
Virtual reality technology is advancing into new and different areas, ranging from pilot training in flight simulators to spatial visualisations, e.g., in architecture and increasingly life-like video games. The possibilities afforded by simulating environments in combination with technology such as VR glasses are practically endless. However, VR systems are still rarely used in everyday applications. “Today, VR is used mainly to consume content. In the case of productivity applications such as in office scenarios, VR still has much potential for development to replace current desktop computers,” says Christian Holz, a professor at ETH Zurich’s Institute for Intelligent Interactive Systems. There is enormous potential indeed: if content were to be no longer limited to a screen, users would be able to leverage the nature of three-dimensional environments, interacting with great flexibility and intuitively with their hands.
Each finger causes different vibration profiles
What’s preventing this from becoming a reality? Holz thinks the main problem lies in the interaction between humans and technology. For example, most of today’s VR applications are either operated with controllers that are held in the user’s hand or with hands in the air, so that the position can be captured by a camera. The user is also typically standing during interaction. “If you have to hold your arms up all the time, it quickly becomes tiring,” says Holz. “This currently prevents normal work processes from becoming possible, as they require interaction with applications for multiple hours.” Typing on a virtual keyboard, for example, presents another problem: the fingers move only slightly and cameras cannot capture the movement as precisely as current mechanical keyboards do. With in-air typing, the usual haptic feedback is also lacking.
For this reason, it's clear to Holz’s research team that passive interfaces will remain important for the viable and productive adoption of VR technology. That could be a classic tabletop, a wall or a person’s own body. For optimal use, the researchers developed a sensory technology called “TapID”, which they will present at the IEEE VR conference at the end of March. The prototype embeds several acceleration sensors in a normal rubber wristband.
These sensors detect when the hand touches a surface and which finger the person has used. The researchers found that their novel sensor design can detect tiny differences in the vibration profile on the wrist in order to differentiate between each characteristic finger movement. A custom machine learning pipeline the researchers developed processes the collected data in real time. In combination with the camera system built into a set of VR glasses, which captures the position of the hands, TapID generates extremely precise input. The researchers have demonstrated this in several applications that they programmed for their development, including a virtual keyboard and a piano (see video).
Virtual piano using the smartwatch
The virtual piano does a particularly good job of demonstrating the advantages of TapID, explains Holz: “Here, both spatial accuracy and timing are essential. The moment at which the keys are touched must be captured with maximum precision. The wrist sensors can do this more reliably than a camera.” The relatively simple technology used by our system offers several advantages; for example, producing this type of wristband should cost only a few francs.
The research team also compared their system with existing technology: in a technical evaluation with 18 participants, they managed to show that TapID not only works reliably with the specially developed electronics in the wristband, but the method could also transfer to existing fitness wristbands and everyday smartwatches, because they are all equipped with inertia sensors. Looking ahead, the researchers plan to continue to improve the technology with more test subjects and develop more applications to integrate TapID into productivity scenarios and to support offices of the futures.
Holz thinks “mobile virtual reality” is another exciting possibility: “Our sensor solution is portable and it has the potential to make VR systems suitable for productivity work on the go. TapID allows users to operate applications with their hand or thighs – anywhere and any time.” As a professor of computer science, Holz sees the future of virtual reality in being able to work together from any physical location – not limited by hardware but as if users were all in the same room. “TapID could be a big enabler in moving into that direction,” he adds. He and his team with Manuel Meier, Paul Streli and Andreas Fender will continue their research in this area.
